Throughout my diverse career path, including a rewarding journey as a professional rugby player, a successful career in sales, and now as a specialist recruitment consultant in the Insurance sector, I've learned that adaptability and an open mind can lead to unexpected and rewarding opportunities. This holds as true on the rugby field as it does within the fast-paced landscape of Insurance.

 

In my current role at Hunter Savage, I've had the opportunity to assist professionals across the Insurance spectrum and the breadth of my experiences has enriched my understanding of the industry and its shifting landscape.

 

One such significant shift that I've observed recently is in the hiring policies within the insurance industry, specifically between Personal Lines and Commercial Lines. In the past, these two areas were distinctly separate, with recruiters seeking specific experience in each. 

 

However, over the last six months, I have seen a remarkable change. Employers' requirements have relaxed, and now candidates with solid experience in Personal Lines are being considered for roles in Commercial Lines, even if they don't have direct experience in the commercial sector. 

 

This trend marks a significant shift in the industry's approach to talent acquisition and is an important development that could potentially reshape career paths in the insurance sector. In this post, I aim to explore this shift in more detail, unpacking its implications for both professionals and employers in the industry.

 

Historical Context: The Dichotomy Between Personal and Commercial Lines

In order to fully appreciate the significance of this recent shift, it's important to first understand the traditional divide between Personal Lines and Commercial Lines within the insurance industry.

Personal Lines Insurance

This type of insurance primarily covers individuals against potential loss. This can be as a result of various factors including:
 

  • Death or injury (Life and Health Insurance)
  • Loss of property (Homeowners or Motor Insurance)
  • Personal liability (Personal Liability Insurance)

Commercial Lines Insurance

On the other hand, this type of insurance is designed with businesses in mind. It provides coverage for various potential losses, such as:
 

  • Theft or property damage (Commercial Property Insurance)
  • Liability (General Liability Insurance)
  • Business interruptions (Business Interruption Insurance)
  • Injured employees (Workers' Compensation Insurance)

 

Historically, there has been a distinct divide between these two areas. This is primarily due to the different sets of skills, knowledge, and expertise required. Personal Lines often deal with more straightforward, standardised policies, focusing on individual clients with personal insurance needs. Commercial Lines, conversely, deal with a more diverse range of policy types and typically require a greater understanding of business needs, legal issues, and risk assessment.

 

This has traditionally led to distinct career paths within the industry, with professionals specialising in either Personal Lines or Commercial Lines. Recruiters and employers typically sought candidates with specific experience in each respective field. For example, if a company was hiring for a Commercial Lines role, they would usually require candidates to have a certain amount of experience directly in Commercial Lines. The rationale was that commercial insurance involves more complexity and therefore requires more experience or specialised knowledge.

The Changing Trends

In recent times, however, I've noticed a significant shift in hiring trends within the insurance industry. The once rigid boundaries between Personal and Commercial Lines are becoming increasingly fluid.

 

Over the past six months, there's been a notable softening in the hiring requirements for Commercial Lines roles. Where companies previously insisted on at least a year of direct Commercial Lines experience, many are now open to considering candidates with a strong background in Personal Lines. In fact, some clients are accepting candidates with no direct Commercial Lines experience, as long as they've spent at least 2-3 years in Personal Lines roles. This shift represents a significant departure from traditional norms.

 

But what's driving this change? I believe there are several factors at play:
 

  • Talent Shortage: In today's competitive job market, companies are struggling to find skilled Commercial Lines professionals. This shortage has led many to consider a wider pool of candidates, including those with a strong track record in Personal Lines.
  • Transferable Skills: There's a growing recognition that many skills gained in Personal Lines are transferable to Commercial Lines. Skills such as customer service, policy administration, claims management, and understanding insurance regulations are applicable across both lines.
  • The Learning Curve: Companies are now more open to investing in training and development. They recognise that with the right training, a professional from Personal Lines can quickly get up to speed with the nuances of Commercial Lines. This openness to training also indicates a shift towards a longer-term view of talent development.
  • The Pandemic Effect: The COVID-19 pandemic has forced many industries, including insurance, to re-evaluate traditional ways of doing things. This has led to more flexible approaches in many areas, including hiring policies.

 

In essence, the lines between Personal and Commercial insurance roles are blurring. Employers are beginning to value the skills and potential of candidates over their specific past experiences, a trend that could lead to profound changes in the industry.

 

What this shift means for professionals in Personal Lines

This evolving landscape within the insurance industry holds significant implications for Personal Lines professionals. The shift in hiring policies broadens horizons, opening doors to new opportunities that might have previously seemed inaccessible.

 

The primary implication of this shift is that it greatly expands career opportunities for Personal Lines professionals. No longer are they limited to their specific domain; they now have a chance to venture into the Commercial Lines realm. This trend is breaking down traditional barriers, providing greater fluidity and flexibility in career progression within the insurance industry.

 

Insights into making the transition to Commercial Lines

For those considering such a transition, it's important to understand that while some skills are transferable, there will still be a learning curve involved. Here are a few steps to ease this transition:
 

  • Education and Training: Consider upskilling through industry-recognised qualifications or courses. This could be a diploma or certificate course in commercial insurance or risk management.
  • Networking: Networking within the industry can offer invaluable insights and opportunities. Joining industry associations or attending events could help in understanding the commercial sector's nuances and making valuable connections.
  • Leverage Transferable Skills: Highlight your transferable skills during your application process. Show potential employers how your experience in personal lines has equipped you with skills applicable to commercial roles.
  • Mentorship: Seek mentorship from someone already working in commercial lines. Their guidance and advice can provide a roadmap to navigate your career transition.

 

Exploring the benefits of this transition

Making a move from Personal Lines to Commercial Lines can offer a host of benefits:

 

Diversification: It provides an opportunity to diversify your skills and experience, making you a more rounded insurance professional.

 

Increased Earning Potential: Typically, Commercial Lines roles can offer higher remuneration compared to Personal Lines, due to their increased complexity and risk.

 

Growth Opportunities: With more companies open to hiring Personal Lines professionals for Commercial roles, there's an increased likelihood of finding roles with greater responsibility and career advancement opportunities.

 

This shift in hiring policies is reshaping the future of insurance careers, offering new paths for those willing to embrace change and seize the opportunity.

 

Implications for Employers

Just as this shift holds implications for professionals within the industry, it also affects employers and their hiring practices. Employers are the driving force behind this change, recognising the potential of Personal Lines professionals to bring value to their Commercial Lines operations.

 

Understanding why employers are opening up to this shift

Several factors are motivating employers to revise their hiring practices:

 

Talent Shortage: With a scarcity of skilled professionals in the Commercial Lines domain, employers are looking at Personal Lines as a new talent pool to explore.

 

Investing in Potential: Employers are realising the value of investing in individuals with strong insurance fundamentals, customer service skills, and a willingness to learn, rather than being overly prescriptive about specific Commercial Lines experience.

 

Adaptability: The recent global events have taught businesses the importance of being adaptable. This includes being more flexible in their approach to hiring, which can ultimately create a more diverse and resilient workforce.

 

Potential benefits for companies looking to hire experienced insurance professionals

By opening up Commercial Lines roles to experienced Personal Lines professionals, companies stand to gain several benefits:

 

Increased Talent Pool: This approach expands the potential talent pool, providing a greater choice of candidates for Commercial Lines roles.

 

Transferable Skills: Personal Lines professionals bring with them a set of transferable skills, such as excellent customer service, policy administration, and an understanding of regulatory requirements.

 

New Perspectives: Professionals transitioning from Personal Lines can bring fresh perspectives and innovative solutions to Commercial Lines, having dealt with a different set of clients and insurance products.

 

Employee Development and Retention: Providing Personal Lines professionals with pathways to transition into Commercial Lines can increase job satisfaction, improve employee development, and aid retention.

 

By being open to this shift, employers can access a wider talent pool, bring fresh perspectives to their teams, and potentially improve employee retention. It's a win-win situation, with both employers and employees standing to benefit from this more flexible approach to hiring in the insurance industry.

 

Broader Impacts on the Insurance Industry

The shift we're discussing is not just a movement within a few companies or a temporary response to talent shortages; it represents a larger trend that could have substantial implications for the insurance industry as a whole.

 

The flexibility in hiring policies is pushing the industry towards a more holistic, inclusive, and adaptive approach. The traditional boundaries that defined and separated different lines of insurance are blurring, leading to a more integrated view of the industry.

 

Here are some potential impacts:

 

Greater Workforce Fluidity: With easier transition between Personal and Commercial Lines, professionals will enjoy increased career fluidity. This could potentially result in a more dynamic, adaptable workforce.

 

Improved Industry Appeal: As career paths in the insurance industry become more flexible, it could make the industry more appealing to new entrants and reduce talent shortages.

 

Increased Innovation: A workforce with diverse experiences and backgrounds often results in increased innovation. Cross-pollination of ideas from different lines of insurance could foster creative solutions to complex challenges.

 

Possibility of Similar Trends Emerging in Other Areas

As this shift gains momentum, it's possible that similar trends could emerge in other areas of the insurance industry. We might see a decrease in the strict categorisation of roles and an increase in the value placed on transferable skills and potential. This could extend to other sectors within the insurance industry, such as Life and Health, Property and Casualty, or even across different functions, like underwriting, claims, and sales.

 

Ultimately, this trend reflects a broader move towards a more adaptable, skills-focused approach in the job market. As we continue to navigate the ever-changing landscape of the insurance industry, one thing is clear: flexibility, adaptability, and a willingness to learn are becoming increasingly important in forging a successful career in insurance.

 

Preparing for the Future

As the landscape of the insurance industry continues to evolve, it is critical for both professionals and employers to stay agile and proactive. Embracing change and future-proofing careers and organisations will be key to thriving in this new era.

 

Advice for Professionals

If you're a professional in Personal Lines considering a move to Commercial Lines, here are some steps you could take:

 

Continuous Learning: Stay informed about the latest trends and changes in the industry. Seek out professional development opportunities, engage in lifelong learning, and maintain a growth mindset.

 

Skills Development: Enhance your skill set with new abilities relevant to Commercial Lines. This could include risk analysis, understanding complex business structures, and gaining knowledge of commercial insurance products.

 

Build a Network: Establish connections with professionals already in the Commercial Lines sector. They can offer valuable advice, support, and potential job opportunities.

 

A Word for Employers

 

For employers looking to adapt to this shift, consider the following:
 

  1. Talent Development: Develop comprehensive training programmes to equip Personal Lines professionals with the skills necessary to succeed in Commercial Lines roles.
  2. Recruitment Strategy: Adjust your recruitment strategy to focus on potential and transferable skills, rather than specific past experience.
  3. Create a Supportive Environment: Provide mentorship and support for professionals transitioning from Personal Lines to Commercial Lines. This will facilitate smoother transitions and increase the likelihood of success.

 

Future-Proofing Careers and Companies in the Insurance Industry

Looking ahead, the key to future-proofing careers and companies in the insurance industry lies in embracing change and fostering adaptability. For professionals, it means seizing opportunities to diversify skills and experiences. For employers, it's about recognising the value in transferable skills and potential, fostering a culture of learning and development, and being flexible in their approach to talent acquisition and management.

 

In this evolving landscape, those who adapt quickly, stay resilient, and commit to continuous learning will be well-positioned to seize the opportunities that come their way. This shift in the insurance industry doesn't just mark a change in hiring practices - it signals a broader evolution towards a more flexible, inclusive and future-ready industry.

 

Conclusion

As the insurance industry continues to evolve, we're seeing a significant shift in the dynamics between Personal and Commercial Lines. This opens up new opportunities for professionals and allows employers to tap into previously unexplored talent pools.

 

For professionals in Personal Lines, this trend represents fresh avenues for career advancement. For employers, it's an opportunity to bring in diverse experiences and innovative perspectives to their operations.

 

At Hunter Savage, we're dedicated to helping professionals and employers navigate this changing landscape. We believe in connecting talent with opportunities and aiding companies in assembling robust, versatile teams.

 

I urge both professionals considering the transition to Commercial Lines and employers adjusting to these changes to approach this shift with an open mind. The future of our industry is dynamic, requiring flexibility, innovation, and resilience.

 

Remember, in this evolving landscape, Hunter Savage is your partner in navigating these changes. We're just a conversation away, ready to support you in exploring the possibilities that lie ahead.

 

For more information, or to speak to me in confidence, feel free to contact me via the details below:

E: paddy@huntersavage.com

T: 015 259662  M: 019 069649  

 

 

Share

#

get in touch

  • Belfast
    3rd Floor,
    65-67 Chichester St
    Belfast, BT1 4JD
    Phone: 028 9008 0031
  • Dublin
    38 to 39 Fitzwilliam
    Square, Dublin 2
    Phone: 01 906 9649
  • Edinburgh
    5 Albany Street,
    Edinburgh, EH1 3QB
    Phone: 0131 566 0032
  • Manchester
    53 King Street,
    Manchester, M2 4LQ
    Phone: 0161 4166 016
  • London
    Blackwell House,
    Guildhall Yard,
    London, EC2V 5AE
    Phone: 0203 633 8163
Our Charity Partners
charity-partner-logo-1 charity-partner-logo-1
We are members of
charity-partner-logo-1
© 2025 Hunter Savage